---
title: Your diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives are missing the point. Here’s how to fix them | Hartley McMaster
description: Despite everyone’s best intentions, diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives often fail to go beyond checklist exercises. Can this change?
image: https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/hubfs/diversity-and-inclusion-1.png
---
[Skip to the main content.](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/your-diversity-equity-and-inclusion-initiatives-are-missing-the-point.-heres-how-to-fix-them#main-content)
[](https://www.hmcm.co.uk)
[](https://www.hmcm.co.uk)
- [Tel: +44 (0)20 4583 4513](tel:+442045834513)
- [Company](https://www.hmcm.co.uk/company)
- [Insights](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights)
- [Contact Us](https://meetings-eu1.hubspot.com/tom-dewar/web-enquiry)
[](https://hubspot-cta-redirect-eu1-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/cta/redirect/25327253/0acd864d-b25e-45d9-9827-af55d4ac0405)
Toggle Menu
Toggle Menu
[](https://hubspot-cta-redirect-eu1-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/cta/redirect/25327253/0acd864d-b25e-45d9-9827-af55d4ac0405)
- [Tel: +44 (0)20 4583 4513](tel:+442045834513)
- [Company](https://www.hmcm.co.uk/company)
- [Insights](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights)
- [Contact Us](https://meetings-eu1.hubspot.com/tom-dewar/web-enquiry)
[*Facebook*](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/your-diversity-equity-and-inclusion-initiatives-are-missing-the-point.-heres-how-to-fix-them#0) [*Instagram*](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/your-diversity-equity-and-inclusion-initiatives-are-missing-the-point.-heres-how-to-fix-them#0) [*LinkedIn*](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/your-diversity-equity-and-inclusion-initiatives-are-missing-the-point.-heres-how-to-fix-them#0) [*Twitter*](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/your-diversity-equity-and-inclusion-initiatives-are-missing-the-point.-heres-how-to-fix-them#0) [*Youtube*](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/your-diversity-equity-and-inclusion-initiatives-are-missing-the-point.-heres-how-to-fix-them#0) [*Medium*](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/your-diversity-equity-and-inclusion-initiatives-are-missing-the-point.-heres-how-to-fix-them#0)
##### Column Headline
- Testing 1
- Sub Nav 1
- Sub Nav 2
- Testing 2
- Testing 3
##### Column Headline
- Testing 1
- Sub Nav 1
- Sub Nav 2
- Testing 2
- Testing 3
- Testing 1
- Sub Nav 1
- Sub Nav 2
- Testing 2
- Testing 3
3 min read
# Your diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives are missing the point. Here’s how to fix them
[ Garkay Wong](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/author/garkay-wong) Mar 2021
[data leadership](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/tag/data-leadership)
*It is very difficult for diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives to go beyond checklist exercises despite everyone’s best intentions. Much of this has to do with the competing incentives that naturally appear whenever aspects of social good are introduced into profit driven organizations. However, there is a way to incorporate DEI into corporate decision-making to help establish stakeholder alignment about the correct balance between these competing goals. This involves a clever analytical technique that ensures that marginalized voices are guaranteed to have their input included even in organizations with dominating personalities.*
- Diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives are crucial to our pandemic response but have been among the first to be cut;
- Minorities and the economically vulnerable have suffered the most from the virus and its economic impacts;
- Tying DEI initiatives to business outcomes will ensure their robustness in times of crisis.
Governments have always had to deal with complex and conflicting criteria in their decision-making processes. Take cost versus the quality of services, for example. Increasingly we are seeing private enterprises grappling with similar issues under the label of ESG (environmental, social and governance factors).
Diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) is a major component of ESG, but most DEI initiatives are treated as risk-avoidance exercises rather than drivers of positive business outcomes. If the investment case for ESG is here to stay, as current trends seem to suggest, then there is a practical reason for integrating DEI criteria into existing incentive structures.
Incentives should be aligned so that DEI, beyond just being the right thing to do, is also the profitable thing to do. There are a variety of existing methodologies that allow for the integration of both DEI perspectives and goals into corporate decision-making processes. These methodologies are broadly categorized under Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) and, of these, the [Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)](https://www.ifm.eng.cam.ac.uk/research/dstools/analytical-hierarchy-process/) is proving to be easiest for corporate leaders to embrace.
#### Incorporate diversity, equity and inclusion into your decision-making
The AHP was developed in the 1970s by Professor Thomas L. Saaty as a support tool for decisions containing either conflicting criteria or objectives or high levels of subjectivity. It is rooted in mathematics and psychology and has historically been used to:
- Structure business problems;
- Build criteria upon which to judge potential solutions; and
- Select the most suitable solution(s) based on the criteria.
A critical question from a DEI perspective might be: “how do we ensure our decision processes benefit from diverse voices and that those decisions are derived in an inclusionary and equitable manner?” While AHP wasn’t designed specifically to address DEI, its underlying structure ensures that diverse voices can be incorporated into a decision model in the following ways:
- Draw out, via facilitated AHP, diverse views from employees in the decision-making process;
- Build DEI criteria directly into the model to enable those factors to influence business outcomes.
AHP helps business leaders hear from and take advantage of these diverse voices to evaluate how closely proposed alternatives align with organizational objectives. Besides ranking only traditional criteria such as profitability or risk, we can also rank those against stakeholder views on diversity and inclusion to develop a properly weighted profile against which to assess decision alternatives.
#### Create an open dialogue around diverging priorities
In practice, the use of AHP in and of itself already aids in the collection of diverse viewpoints in making a decision, even if DEI isn’t explicitly defined as an objective. This is because its structure controls for cognitive bias, ensures that viewpoints are collected just prior to active discussion of the topic and uncovers areas of disagreement.
In other words, AHP provides a platform (anonymized where it’s warranted) where even the most junior or soft-spoken stakeholder can feel safe to share their opinion; opinions that senior stakeholders would not otherwise have heard or thought to consider. In the current way of doing things, it isn’t uncommon for many diverse opinions to remain unshared because stakeholders don’t wish to get into an argument with the CEO or otherwise feel exposed. Uncovering conflicting viewpoints provides a valuable opportunity for stakeholders to exchange insights around diverging priorities. A consensus is built around a set of core values against which all decisions can be measured.
#### The values-based future of organizations
The final step of the process allows decision-makers to evaluate how closely different decisions align with the organization’s objectives. Those objectives take into consideration the relative preferences of all stakeholders involved. The process ensures transparency and the ability to audit how a decision was made, increases satisfaction with the decision and trust in the model and avoids “hidden” disagreements that can undermine implementation. Far from being just a feel-good exercise, AHP has a proven, demonstrable and well-documented track record of improving business outcomes by doing the following:
1. Build buy-in for DEI initiatives through a participatory process where stakeholders feel they have not just a seat at the table, but also a voice;
2. Enable stakeholders (especially women and minorities) to integrate their knowledge and viewpoints into the decision model;
3. Increase trust that decision was made in an equitable and inclusionary manner;
4. Allow business outcomes to be influenced by DEI objectives.
There are some things to watch out for. The AHP methodology could be misused to provide false justification that decision outcomes had considered diverse views if those views were overwhelmed when mathematically aggregated with those of other decision participants. Experienced practitioners can help mitigate these issues and ensure models are deployed responsibly.
If the pandemic has proven anything, it is that financial performance must be evaluated alongside long-term value for society and the environment. The integration of values-based decision-making will be a critical success factor for the long-term survival of companies.
*This article was originally published in the [World Economic Forum i](https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/03/how-to-improve-diversity-equity-inclusion-initiatives-business/)n March 2021 .*
- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)
[](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/connecting-posit-workbench-to-github-with-https)
#### [Connecting Posit Workbench (RStudio) to GitHub with HTTPS](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/connecting-posit-workbench-to-github-with-https)
 [Tom Dewar](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/author/tom-dewar): Mar 2023
If you're an RStudio user using Posit Workbench and want to use GitHub for source control (you should), this is the guide for you. There are two ways...
[technical tips](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/tag/technical-tips)
[Read More](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/connecting-posit-workbench-to-github-with-https)
[](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/maximise-value-from-data-analytics)
#### [How to maxmise value from data analytics](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/maximise-value-from-data-analytics)
 [Tom Dewar](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/author/tom-dewar): Mar 2023
Many companies investing in data analytics struggle to achieve the full value of their investment, perhaps even becoming disillusioned. To understand...
[data leadership](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/tag/data-leadership)
[Read More](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/maximise-value-from-data-analytics)
[](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/five-ways-data-can-help-your-business-navigate-stormy-waters)
#### [Five ways data can help your business navigate stormy waters](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/five-ways-data-can-help-your-business-navigate-stormy-waters)
 [Tom Dewar](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/author/tom-dewar): Oct 2022
We are cursed to live in interesting times. As I write this, a war in Ukraine rumbles on, we sit on the tail of a pandemic and at the jaws of a...
[data leadership](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/tag/data-leadership)
[Read More](https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/five-ways-data-can-help-your-business-navigate-stormy-waters)
##### Get our latest insights
Get our latest insights
Hartley McMaster is an independent management consultancy specialising in the use of analytical and structured methods to solve business problems.
##### London
London
167-169 Great Portland Street
5th Floor
London, W1W 5PF
United Kingdom
T: +44 (0) 20 4583 4513
[E: contact@hmcm.co.uk](mailto:contact@hmcm.co.uk)
##### Hong Kong
Hong Kong
1104 Crawford House
70 Queen's Road Central
Central
Hong Kong
T: +(852) 5346 5400
[E: contact@hmcm.com.hk](mailto:contact@hmcm.com.hk)
[](https://www.hmcm.co.uk)
- [Privacy Policy](https://www.hmcm.co.uk/privacy-policy)
© 2026 Hartley McMaster Ltd
[*Twitter*](https://twitter.com/hartleymcmaster)[*LinkedIn*](https://www.linkedin.com/company/hartley-mcmaster/)
*Return to Top*
```json
{
"@context" : "https://schema.org",
"@type" : "BlogPosting",
"author" : {
"@type" : "Person",
"name" : "Garkay Wong",
"url" : "https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/author/garkay-wong"
},
"dateModified" : "2022-09-20T07:55:27.412Z",
"datePublished" : "2021-03-31T05:16:00.000Z",
"headline" : "Your diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives are missing the point. Here’s how to fix them | Hartley McMaster",
"image" : [ "https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/hubfs/diversity-and-inclusion-1.png" ],
"mainEntityOfPage" : {
"@id" : "https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/insights/your-diversity-equity-and-inclusion-initiatives-are-missing-the-point.-heres-how-to-fix-them",
"@type" : "WebPage"
},
"publisher" : {
"@type" : "Organization",
"logo" : {
"@type" : "ImageObject",
"url" : "https://blog.hmcm.co.uk/hubfs/logos/HMCM%20logo%20two-colour%20STANDARD%20100h.png"
},
"name" : "Hartley McMaster Ltd"
}
}
```